29 Apr 2008 12:25:15
rms
Race Report: Big Sur Marathon

2008 Big Sur Marathon
http://www.bsim.org
A few (warning hi-res) pics at http://home.flash.net/~rsquires/moo/

You lucked out on the weather! said one of the volunteers, as we stood in
line pre-dawn for the buses to the start line: 55F, someone mentioned
nearby, unseasonably warm; apparently 40s are typical for race day, and the
Catalina start last month was in the 30s. I recall reading that this year
the major cyclical ocean currents have changed, perhaps that explains it? A
perfect day in any case, with California condors circling far above the
starting line. I saw redwing blackbirds, scrubjays, and acorn woodpeckers
later on.

As we waited, Jeff Galloway, a race vet, expressed misgivings about the
warmth, while warning us not to drink more than 4-6oz at each waterstop.
'Maybe for the elites', I thought. 'Babbling.' 'This guy's batshit crazy!'
And proceeded to refill my 20oz bottle with gatorade at most of the 13
waterstops. Along with a 24oz bottle pre-race, fresh strawberries, banana
pieces, Scaps, and snakeoil (Mona Vie and FRS) packets along the way.

My performance was astoundingly mediocre, 4:30 putting me exactly at
mid-pack. Though volunteers called out split-times every mile or two,
having no sense of pace to begin with this meant little to me, and with the
presence of so many people from mixed entry classes and the festival
atmosphere, I tended to run with the crowd. At Catalina with many fewer
people I naturally focused on catching up with someone ahead without being
aware of it, which, along with the cooler temps probably accounts for the
lower 4:15 time there (and Catalina probably isn't a full marathon distance
anyway).

Jeff Galloway repeatedly said pre-race to take short strides downhill to
avoid muscle overextension, and to save resources for the second half, and
that advice I certainly did take, slowing down whenever my hamstrings
started tightening up, though actually walking very little. I was never in
distress of any kind, had no cramping in the race, only one brief pee stop
at mid-point, and at 20miles did wake up a bit and began picking up the pace
slightly, gradually accelerating til the last mile I was sprinting (well,
'sprinting') all the way to the finish. It did feel good sweeping past
droves of people, though most of them were walkers! No cramping post-race,
and a 5mile walk to the airport later on worked out much of the muscle
stiffness. Interestingly, I noticed none of the salt trails I usually get
on my face or shirt. Whether this is a result of the higher humidity or an
indication that my body chemistry is more balanced now, I have no idea, but
for now I'll take it as a sign that drinking more is a good thing.

Equipment-wise, I wanted to dispense with sunscreen entirely, and wore a
longsleeve coolmax jersey (I've ordered a couple plain white ones for future
use), sunhat, and a pair of fingerless 'sun gloves', marketed to canoers,
from REI. There are a couple other makers of these type of summer gloves,
marketed towards fishermen, but most stores are totally clueless about
specialty items like this. The REI gloves worked perfectly but do look a
bit odd, and if anyone's tried the Columbia glove I'd like to hear a review!
Here are links to a few different models:
http://www.spfstore.com/Columbia-PFG-Fingerless-Glove-p/su9207.htm

http://www.ramseyoutdoor.com/products/details.aspx?g=mens+clothing&sg=gloves&ssg=&pid=SUNGLOVESM

http://www.rei.com/product/685194

Also, I ditched the lapbelt waterbottles for this race and got a handheld
model at the race expo:
http://www.ultimatedirection.com/product.php?id=12&page=handhelds
I loved it, and wish it was useable in all races. Tying up both hands by
carrying two seems like a bad idea to me though while trailrunning, but you
see many photos of runners doing exactly that, so who knows, but the
prospect of ditching the clip-on belt for these and a pair of racing shorts
with multiple external stitched-on pockets is attractive.

Next race: Jemez Mountain 50mile Trail Run
http://www.highaltitudeathletics.org/JemezMt.htm
I'm not quite as frightened of this as I was before Big Sur, and am thinking
that, as long as I slow down when my muscles begin tightening up, take
shorter strides and avoid overextending on downhills, and maintain a
constant fluid intake (I'm aiming at 64oz per hour -- the Jemez will be much
hotter, much drier, and much higher up than these wimpy kidstuff California
runs), I might finish with some dignity and not be walking 20miles with a
mass of cramps for legs. We'll see!

rms




30 Apr 2008 21:50:20
jobs
Re: Race Report: Big Sur Marathon

rms wrote:
> 2008 Big Sur Marathon
> http://www.bsim.org
> A few (warning hi-res) pics at http://home.flash.net/~rsquires/moo/

Nice pics. I've driven through that area many times and it's always
green. The piano-man shot was cool. What did he play? :)

>
> You lucked out on the weather! said one of the volunteers, as we stood in
> line pre-dawn for the buses to the start line: 55F, someone mentioned
> nearby, unseasonably warm; apparently 40s are typical for race day, and the
> Catalina start last month was in the 30s. I recall reading that this year
> the major cyclical ocean currents have changed, perhaps that explains it? A
> perfect day in any case, with California condors circling far above the
> starting line. I saw redwing blackbirds, scrubjays, and acorn woodpeckers
> later on.

55F is very nice. Was it windy at all?

> My performance was astoundingly mediocre, 4:30 putting me exactly at
> mid-pack.

But, it's still a marathon.

> Though volunteers called out split-times every mile or two,
> having no sense of pace to begin with this meant little to me,

The hilly course would mess it up anyway, if you're not experienced enough.

>
> Jeff Galloway repeatedly said pre-race to take short strides downhill to
> avoid muscle overextension, and to save resources for the second half, and
> that advice I certainly did take, slowing down whenever my hamstrings
> started tightening up, though actually walking very little. I was never in
> distress of any kind, had no cramping in the race, only one brief pee stop
> at mid-point, and at 20miles did wake up a bit and began picking up the pace
> slightly, gradually accelerating til the last mile I was sprinting (well,
> 'sprinting') all the way to the finish. It did feel good sweeping past
> droves of people, though most of them were walkers! No cramping post-race,
> and a 5mile walk to the airport

You walked 5 miles after that?

> later on worked out much of the muscle
> stiffness. Interestingly, I noticed none of the salt trails I usually get
> on my face or shirt.

I get that when it's really hot. In cooler temperatures, even if I sweat
a ton, I don't get them.

> Also, I ditched the lapbelt waterbottles for this race and got a handheld
> model at the race expo:
> http://www.ultimatedirection.com/product.php?id=12&page=handhelds

Doesn't it hurt your arms/hands?

> I loved it, and wish it was useable in all races. Tying up both hands by
> carrying two seems like a bad idea to me though while trailrunning,

Maybe for better balance? ;-)

> but you
> see many photos of runners doing exactly that, so who knows, but the
> prospect of ditching the clip-on belt for these and a pair of racing shorts
> with multiple external stitched-on pockets is attractive.
>
> Next race: Jemez Mountain 50mile Trail Run

Good luck.

Thanks for the race report.
jobs

** Posted from http://www.teranews.com**


01 May 2008 05:03:33
Re: Race Report: Big Sur Marathon

On Apr 29, 2:25=A0pm, "rms" <rsqui...@REMOVEflashMOO.net > wrote:

snip

Thanks for the report I guess. Sounds like nice weather and pretty
scenery.

As far as a minor rant goes, I am just not understanding the desire of
so many people to enter in these kind of "participation-athons" or
"survive-athons". Is it some kind of thing to tell people that you
know socially, or at work, etc "I am a marathoner?".

When people talk about passing people for miles who are walking well
it just doesn't sound like a race at all.

There are certainly people making money "training" others in how to
"race" these kinds of distances. Financially I guess also for the
event organizers it makes sense to encourage as many entries as you
can accomodate.

On the positive side it is certainly more healthy than sitting on the
couch watching television. But calling it a "race" ... questionable
in my mind anyhow.



01 May 2008 13:25:47
Tim Downie
Re: Race Report: Big Sur Marathon

rms wrote:

>
> As we waited, Jeff Galloway, a race vet, expressed misgivings about
> the warmth, while warning us not to drink more than 4-6oz at each
> waterstop. 'Maybe for the elites', I thought. 'Babbling.' 'This
> guy's batshit crazy!' And proceeded to refill my 20oz bottle with gatorade
> at most of the 13
> waterstops.

Why? Were you that thirsty?

[...]

> Interestingly, I noticed none of the salt trails I
> usually get on my face or shirt. Whether this is a result of the higher
> humidity
> or an indication that my body chemistry is more balanced now, I have no
> idea, but for now I'll take it as a sign that drinking more is a good
> thing.

I think that's a dangerous assumption, or at least not one justified by that
bit of evidence.

Sure, your weather conditions were a million miles removed from mine (this
is what it was like for the first half
http://www.zen31010.zen.co.uk/highlandflingrace/images/fling08images/winners/DSC_0012.JPG)
but nor was it *that* hot.

As I've tried to point out, nobody dies from a bit of dehydration.
Overhydration is far more dangerous. Of course you have to find out what is
best for *you* and I can't know that from here. Just don't go making
assumptions based on dodgy evidence.

[...]

> Next race: Jemez Mountain 50mile Trail Run
> http://www.highaltitudeathletics.org/JemezMt.htm
> I'm not quite as frightened of this as I was before Big Sur, and am
> thinking that, as long as I slow down when my muscles begin tightening up,
> take
> shorter strides and avoid overextending on downhills, and maintain a
> constant fluid intake (I'm aiming at 64oz per hour -- the Jemez will
> be much hotter, much drier, and much higher up than these wimpy kidstuff
> California runs),

So you're planning on taking every hour what I took over about 9 hours? ;-)

Not disagreeing with the need for more in that environment though. I really
think for an ultra distance trail you should be basing you requirements on
*thirst*, not any preconcievd idea of what you *should* be doing. Second
guessing mother nature over that sort of distance could be dangerous.

>I might finish with some dignity and not be walking 20miles
> with a mass of cramps for legs. We'll see!

Good luck!

Tim




01 May 2008 13:35:12
Tony S.
Re: Race Report: Big Sur Marathon

"rms" <rsquires@REMOVEflashMOO.net > wrote in message
news:gKJRj.12490$GE1.9919@nlpi061.nbdc.sbc.com...
> 2008 Big Sur Marathon
> http://www.bsim.org
> A few (warning hi-res) pics at http://home.flash.net/~rsquires/moo/
>
>snip<

You seem to be enjoying your tour of a variety of races, thanks for the
report. Sounds like you're becoming more of a runner than a multi-sport
athlete?

> Next race: Jemez Mountain 50mile Trail Run
> http://www.highaltitudeathletics.org/JemezMt.htm
> I'm not quite as frightened of this as I was before Big Sur, and am
> thinking that, as long as I slow down when my muscles begin tightening up,
> take shorter strides and avoid overextending on downhills, and maintain a
> constant fluid intake (I'm aiming at 64oz per hour -- the Jemez will be
> much hotter, much drier, and much higher up than these wimpy kidstuff
> California runs), I might finish with some dignity and not be walking
> 20miles with a mass of cramps for legs. We'll see!
>
> rms

Wow, now that looks like some nice terrain and a really tough race. Serious
elevation and altitude there. Have you done a 50 before? Await your report
on that one! Looks like a quad-buster to me.

-Tony




01 May 2008 10:06:01
rms
Re: Race Report: Big Sur Marathon

> Why? Were you that thirsty?

Firstly, please understand my 'jeff galloway' comments were not a
backhanded snipe at your own excellent report. I wrote that well before
seeing that thread. As for Jeff Galloway himself, well drinking many
gallons of plain water certainly *is* a bad idea. But people tend to stick
to what they learned in the past, and sportsdrinks didn't even exist 20
years ago.

I think the 'maintain a constant weight' approach is better for me. I
already know from long run & bike efforts locally that I lose many lbs
during the course of them, and that post/during-event muscle aches/cramping
seem highly correlated with how much I intake pre/during. In general, the 5
marathon events I've done so far this year have been my most consistent and
successful, in large part I believe from increasing my intake. No I have
not gotten faster, but that's a separate training issue. The only times
I've felt bad lately are when I'm out by myself and lose track of time and
intake.

My main concern now is feeling good during and after the event, and in
that respect this last event was the most successful ever for me: I
performed at the same level as the last four previous, while experiencing no
cramp twinges either during or after, and now a few days later feel
essentially the same as before the event. While increasing my intake during
and after. This time I also drank a quart of decaf greentea (I tear the
bags open and drink the leaves also) + EmergenC electrolyte/vitamin packets
+ weak gatorade twice a day after the event, and find it has a nice
loosening effect on stiff muscles. I'm thinking lots of electrolytes and
anti-oxidants are beneficial.

In any case, how much did I actually drink during this event? Around 2
gallons. 2 gallons over 5 hours, boy that looks miles away from any danger
zone to me, when it's not plain water, and I'm taking electrolyte capsules,
and weighed basically the same before and after. Glancing at the intake
table in the back of Karnazes' book for his 200mile run, he drank around
5oz/mile, and I drank 10. Well, he's 8" shorter, 20lbs lighter. And his
rate of food intake looks quite high.

> Sure, your weather conditions were a million miles removed from mine (this
> is what it was like for the first half
> http://www.zen31010.zen.co.uk/highlandflingrace/images/fling08images/winners/DSC_0012.JPG

Oy. It was actually raining for a full marathon distance in your race?
100% humidity and the cooling effect of rain makes a profound difference in
your intake levels. I've experienced this myself running in rain in the
mountains here: even my *eyes* feel better in high humidity -- my contacts
maintain a higher hydration level and I actually see better. This is indeed
a million miles removed from 8% humidity, 70F+ and 6000-10000ft conditions
that I run/bike in here locally.

And *huge* kudos and highfives for your performance. After shuffling
through my first 50k at Palo Duro last year I hung around to see the 50mile
winner come in. I was jumping and pumping my fists, more excited than he
was :) Eagerly awaiting a detailed race report from your 100miler with
lots of pics!

rms




01 May 2008 10:55:26
Re: Race Report: Big Sur Marathon

I've run 2 BSIM's before and this was by far the hottest-ever race
day. Saturday the high was 72, unheard of in Carmel in April. I
thought the organization of the race was great, as always. So was the
Sam Adams beer in the tent at the end of the race. Hurricane Point, as
always, was hell, as were the Carmel Highlands and slant of the road.

As for hydrating, I drink 24 ounces per hour, every hour of a
marathon. You need to hydrate, especially on a course in direct
sunlight with limited shade. In any case, it's the best marathon I've
ever run in, the most scenic and best organized. The volunteers are
awesome!



01 May 2008 19:32:28
Dot
Re: Race Report: Big Sur Marathon

rms wrote:
> sportsdrinks didn't even exist 20
> years ago.

Just for clarification: Granted, some folks may not consider gatorade a
sports drink, but gatorade started in late 1960's, over 40 yr ago.
http://www.gatorade.com/history/

And, granted, this wasn't an official sports drink, but "heavily sugared
drinks" were being used by ultra runners in 1967:
http://www.rowan.edu/colleges/las/departments/math/facultystaff/osler/Running.html

And Galloway got his original run/walk concepts from Tom Osler.

Dot

--
"Magic rocks and roots - the ones that trip you but you can never find
afterwards" - Matt Carpenter



01 May 2008 19:46:04
Dot
Re: Race Report: Big Sur Marathon

rms wrote:

> 2008 Big Sur Marathon
> http://www.bsim.org
...
>
> My performance was astoundingly mediocre, 4:30 putting me exactly at
> mid-pack. Though volunteers called out split-times every mile or two,
> having no sense of pace to begin with this meant little to me,

Good job!! If it's a hilly race, the only meaning split times would have
is if you've looked at elevation profile and knew footing conditions
(probably not an issue on road races), and had calculated your own goal
splits.


> and with the
> presence of so many people from mixed entry classes and the festival
> atmosphere,

and then have everything thrown off by crowd anyway.;)


> ...

> I was never in
> distress of any kind, had no cramping in the race, only one brief pee stop
> at mid-point, and at 20miles did wake up a bit and began picking up the pace
> slightly, gradually accelerating til the last mile I was sprinting (well,
> 'sprinting') all the way to the finish.

Sounds like you're starting to get a handle on fluids, electrolytes, fuels.


> It did feel good sweeping past
> droves of people, though most of them were walkers!

Walkers (consistent walking from start) or death-marchers (people who
intended to run whole way but ran out of gas)?


No cramping post-race,
> and a 5mile walk to the airport later on worked out much of the muscle
> stiffness. Interestingly, I noticed none of the salt trails I usually get
> on my face or shirt. Whether this is a result of the higher humidity or an
> indication that my body chemistry is more balanced now, I have no idea, but
> for now I'll take it as a sign that drinking more is a good thing.

I think I'd go more by peeing frequency and color than salt trails
because of humidity issues.

Excellent race. Thanks for the report.

Dot

--
"Magic rocks and roots - the ones that trip you but you can never find
afterwards" - Matt Carpenter



01 May 2008 20:48:55
Tim Downie
Re: Race Report: Big Sur Marathon

rms wrote:
> > Why? Were you that thirsty?
>
> Firstly, please understand my 'jeff galloway' comments were not a
> backhanded snipe at your own excellent report.

Don't fret, I was just remarking at how different our hydration stratagies
were. I don't doubt that a lot of it is down to climate but I do feel that
you're maybe overcompensating.

> I wrote that well
> before seeing that thread. As for Jeff Galloway himself, well drinking
> many
> gallons of plain water certainly *is* a bad idea. But people tend to
> stick to what they learned in the past, and sportsdrinks didn't even exist
> 20 years ago.

You're assuming that "sports drinks" are a good idea and not just marketing
hype. ;-) I've gone from not using them, then being a regular user and keen
advocate, to a doubter.

>
> I think the 'maintain a constant weight' approach is better for
> me.

I don't think there's anything wrong with losing *some* weight. After all
our bodies are adapted to cope with a non-constant supply of water. I think
some keyan athletes would argue that some weight loss is actually a good
thing in a distance endurance event. Less weight to carry around!

> I already know from long run & bike efforts locally that I lose many lbs
> during the course of them, and that post/during-event muscle
> aches/cramping seem highly correlated with how much I intake pre/during.

Don't forget adequacy of training (or inadequacy as the case may be)!

> In
> general, the 5 marathon events I've done so far this year have been my
> most
> consistent and successful, in large part I believe from increasing my
> intake. No I
> have not gotten faster, but that's a separate training issue. The only
> times I've felt bad lately are when I'm out by myself and lose track of
> time and intake.
>
> My main concern now is feeling good during and after the event,
> and in that respect this last event was the most successful ever for me:
> I
> performed at the same level as the last four previous, while
> experiencing no cramp twinges either during or after, and now a few days
> later feel
> essentially the same as before the event. While increasing my intake
> during and after. This time I also drank a quart of decaf greentea

Decaf?? Why miss out on all the goodness? ;-)

> (I tear
> the bags open and drink the leaves also) + EmergenC electrolyte/vitamin
> packets + weak gatorade twice a day after the event, and find it has
> a nice loosening effect on stiff muscles. I'm thinking lots of
> electrolytes
> and anti-oxidants are beneficial.

You don't think just the exercise alone might be doing that? After my first
marathon, I was going downstairs backwards etc., but with every marathon,
the post-race soreness has diminished without the help of electrolytes &
anti-oxidants.

From my point of view, you seem to be accepting every dietary & hydration
fad hook, line and sinker. More and more when I'm thinking about what's
right, I think about what our plains living hunter gatherer ancestors would
have done. They didn't try to "second guess" their hydration or nutrition.
I'm sure they ate when hungry and drank when thirsty as and when water
became available (which may have been very irregularly indeed).

>
> In any case, how much did I actually drink during this event? Around 2
> gallons. 2 gallons over 5 hours, boy that looks miles away from any
> danger zone to me, when it's not plain water, and I'm taking electrolyte
> capsules, and weighed basically the same before and after.

Sounds a lot to me but you have funny small gallons and I'm probably the
progeny of some illicit cross-breeding with a camel. ;-)

> Glancing at the
> intake table in the back of Karnazes' book for his 200mile run, he drank
> around 5oz/mile, and I drank 10. Well, he's 8" shorter, 20lbs
> lighter. And his rate of food intake looks quite high.
>
> > Sure, your weather conditions were a million miles removed from
> > mine (this is what it was like for the first half
> > http://www.zen31010.zen.co.uk/highlandflingrace/images/fling08images/winners/DSC_0012.JPG
>
> Oy. It was actually raining for a full marathon distance in your
> race?

I think it was. Once you're wet through you stop noticing the rain.

> 100% humidity and the cooling effect of rain makes a profound
> difference in your intake levels.

I'll certainly not deny that.

> I've experienced this myself running in rain in
> the mountains here: even my *eyes* feel better in high humidity -- my
> contacts maintain a higher hydration level and I actually see better.
> This is
> indeed a million miles removed from 8% humidity, 70F+ and 6000-10000ft
> conditions that I run/bike in here locally.

Yep, I accept that we have a *much* nicer climate (for running). I feel
sorry for you with all that nasty cancer inducing sunshine. ;-)

>
> And *huge* kudos and highfives for your performance.

Thanks.

> After
> shuffling through my first 50k at Palo Duro last year I hung around to see
> the
> 50mile winner come in. I was jumping and pumping my fists, more excited
> than he was :) Eagerly awaiting a detailed race report from your
> 100miler
> with lots of pics!

And I'll look forward to your 50 miler. It certainly looks tough and you've
got altitude & heat to deal with too. You dont' shy away from the tough
ones, do you?

Regards

Tim
>
> rms




04 May 2008 19:54:25
D Stumpus
Re: Race Report: Big Sur Marathon


"Tim Downie" <timdownie2003@obviousyahoo.co.uk > wrote

> From my point of view, you seem to be accepting every dietary & hydration
> fad hook, line and sinker. More and more when I'm thinking about what's
> right, I think about what our plains living hunter gatherer ancestors
> would have done. They didn't try to "second guess" their hydration or
> nutrition. I'm sure they ate when hungry and drank when thirsty as and
> when water became available (which may have been very irregularly indeed).

Hi Tim, we differ here. I used to drink only when thirsty on my ultras.
After all mother nature gave us a sense of thirst, so drink when thirsty,
right? I cramped every time it was warm until I learned how much weight I
lost and how much I needed to drink. I think some folks have a
well-calibrated hydration meter, and some don't. Mine totally sucks eggs.
Hence the drinking schedules I've developed for myself.

I did a test recently on a 15 mile easy run in cool (55F) weather, and only
sweated 20 oz/hour (600ml). You'd probably gain weight in those
conditions :-)

>> In any case, how much did I actually drink during this event? Around 2
>> gallons. 2 gallons over 5 hours, boy that looks miles away from any
>> danger zone to me, when it's not plain water, and I'm taking electrolyte
>> capsules, and weighed basically the same before and after.
>
> Sounds a lot to me but you have funny small gallons and I'm probably the
> progeny of some illicit cross-breeding with a camel. ;-)

That's about 7.5 litres, I reckon...On a warm day (temps up to 90F), I drank
12 litres in an 8 hour 50 miler, and was pretty dehydrated at the end (had
to drink away leg cramps at mile 42 or so).






06 May 2008 12:26:02
Tim Downie
Re: Race Report: Big Sur Marathon

D Stumpus wrote:
> "Tim Downie" <timdownie2003@obviousyahoo.co.uk> wrote
>
> > From my point of view, you seem to be accepting every dietary &
> > hydration fad hook, line and sinker. More and more when I'm
> > thinking about what's right, I think about what our plains living
> > hunter gatherer ancestors would have done. They didn't try to
> > "second guess" their hydration or nutrition. I'm sure they ate when
> > hungry and drank when thirsty as and when water became available
> > (which may have been very irregularly indeed).
>
> Hi Tim, we differ here. I used to drink only when thirsty on my
> ultras. After all mother nature gave us a sense of thirst, so drink
> when thirsty, right? I cramped every time it was warm until I
> learned how much weight I lost and how much I needed to drink. I
> think some folks have a well-calibrated hydration meter, and some
> don't. Mine totally sucks eggs. Hence the drinking schedules I've
> developed for myself.

I don't think there's anything wrong with drinking schedules, up to a point.
The problem arises when you push beyond your normal boundaries. The body is
pretty well able to cope with getting things a bit wrong, but as the race
distance increases, the ability of the body to cope with overhydration
decreases. I.e., a schedule that would only moderately overhydrate (and
perhaps ward off cramps) in a marathon distance event could potentially be a
very dangerous schedule to follow for a much longer event. Indeed, it is
mistakes like this that have lead to a number of runners in the WHW race
getting hospitalised.

RMS is "pushing the envelope" and I just think he needs to be a bit careful
and not assume that any fixed regime extrapolated from shorter distances is
automatically applicable to a very different event. His 50 miler is going
to take *much* longer than a road marathon and consequently the risks of
getting it wrong increase greatly. I'd far rather read about his
successful completion than about his hospitalisation.

Yes, I know our climate is very different and fluid requirements are less.
Just voicing a word of caution.

Tim





06 May 2008 23:51:54
Ken
Re: Race Report: Big Sur Marathon

In article <sNqdnT2IVs9_64PVnZ2dnUVZ_oytnZ2d@giganews.com >, D Stumpus
<dstumpus_NOSP@mindspring.com > writes
>
>"Tim Downie" <timdownie2003@obviousyahoo.co.uk> wrote
>
>> From my point of view, you seem to be accepting every dietary & hydration
>> fad hook, line and sinker. More and more when I'm thinking about what's
>> right, I think about what our plains living hunter gatherer ancestors
>> would have done. They didn't try to "second guess" their hydration or
>> nutrition. I'm sure they ate when hungry and drank when thirsty as and
>> when water became available (which may have been very irregularly indeed).
>
>Hi Tim, we differ here. I used to drink only when thirsty on my ultras.
>After all mother nature gave us a sense of thirst, so drink when thirsty,
>right? I cramped every time it was warm until I learned how much weight I
>lost and how much I needed to drink. I think some folks have a
>well-calibrated hydration meter, and some don't. Mine totally sucks eggs.
>Hence the drinking schedules I've developed for myself.
>
>I did a test recently on a 15 mile easy run in cool (55F) weather, and only
>sweated 20 oz/hour (600ml). You'd probably gain weight in those
>conditions :-)
>
>>> In any case, how much did I actually drink during this event? Around 2
>>> gallons. 2 gallons over 5 hours, boy that looks miles away from any
>>> danger zone to me, when it's not plain water, and I'm taking electrolyte
>>> capsules, and weighed basically the same before and after.
>>
>> Sounds a lot to me but you have funny small gallons and I'm probably the
>> progeny of some illicit cross-breeding with a camel. ;-)
>
>That's about 7.5 litres, I reckon...On a warm day (temps up to 90F), I drank
>12 litres in an 8 hour 50 miler, and was pretty dehydrated at the end (had
>to drink away leg cramps at mile 42 or so).
>
>
>
>
I've seen primates at the zoo eating the half digested plant remains
that they deliver from their rear end, and it occurs to me that if we
all spent less time talking crapp and more time eating it, we would all
be so much more in tune with our ancestral past, and be free, happy
spirits.
--
Ken